8 common findings in a first ISO surveillance audit and how to fix them
The first surveillance audit takes place about a year after certification. Most findings at this stage come from the same few gaps: documents that were never reviewed, an internal audit with no findings, changes made without a risk assessment, and KPIs that nobody looks at. All of them can be fixed before the auditor arrives.
After the initial certification, many companies put the system aside until the next audit date comes up. The surveillance auditor then checks one thing above all: has the system been used during the year, or has it only been kept on file?
The eight findings below are the ones we see most often in ISO 9001, ISO 14001 and ISO 45001 surveillance audits, with what the standard asks for and what to do about it.
Countries Served
55+
Happy Clients
800+
Technical Experts
50+
Standards Covered
25+
1. Documents never reviewed because "nothing changed"
A common belief is that a policy or procedure signed last year stays current until someone edits it. Clause 7.5 of all three standards expects documents to be reviewed for suitability. An unchanged document still needs a review.
Fix: review each document at the frequency you set. If nothing needs to change, keep the same revision number and record the review date and the name of the reviewer. Update the master list each time a document is added, with a revision status column
2. The internal audit found nothing
An internal audit checklist with every clause marked compliant is one of the first things a certification auditor question. In a year with new products, new documents and new targets, some gaps are normal. A clean result usually means the sample was too small, the checklist was filled in from memory, or the auditor was checking his own work. Clause 9.2 requires auditors to be objective and impartial, so the person who runs the system should not audit it alone.
Fix: use a trained auditor from another department or an external auditor for the areas you manage yourself. Write a short report with findings, not only a filled checklist. Recording your own nonconformities shows the system works.
3. Many templates still use ISO 9001:2008 numbering, such as 5.5.2 for
communication or 5.6 for management review. Under the current structure, communication is 7.4, management review is 9.3, objectives are 6.2 and roles and responsibilities are 5.3.
Fix: check every form that quotes a clause number against the editions you are certified to: ISO 9001:2015 or the new ISO 9001:2026, ISO 14001:2015 and ISO 45001:2018. ISO 9001:2026 was published in September 2026. ISO 9001:2015 certificates remain valid during the transition period, so ask your certification body when it plans to audit you against the new edition.
4. A new product or process with no risk assessment
When a company adds a product line, a machine or a new site, the hazard register and the environmental aspects register should change too. ISO 45001 clause 8.1.3 requires planned changes to be managed before they are implemented.
Fix: raise a management of change form for every new product, process, piece of equipment or layout change. Update the hazard identification and risk assessment and the aspects register before the work starts.
5. Controls chosen without the hierarchy of controls, and no PPE records
Risk registers often list PPE as the main control. ISO 45001 clause 8.1.2 sets an order: eliminate, substitute, engineering controls, administrative controls, and PPE last.
Fix: for each high risk, show which levels of the hierarchy you considered. Keep a PPE matrix by activity and a signed PPE issue record for each worker.
Talk to Our Experts
Claim Your Free Consultation Today!
🔒 Your information is safe with us, We respect your Privacy
Table of Contents
Why Choose Maxicert?
Expert Guidance. Global Standards. Proven Results.
Global Presence
Expert Consultants
End-to-End Support
Fast Turnaround
Comprehensive Solutions
Trusted Worldwide
6. Compliance register with no evaluation
A legal register lists the laws that apply. Clause 9.1.2 of ISO 14001 and ISO 45001 also asks you to evaluate compliance at planned intervals and keep the results. Auditors also check outsourced activities, such as whether your waste contractor holds a valid licence.
Fix: add columns for evaluation date, evidence of compliance, result and evaluator. Keep copies of licences for waste contractors and other service providers, and track their expiry dates.
7. Climate change missing from the context analysis
In February 2024, ISO amended ISO 9001, ISO 14001, ISO 45001 and other management system standards. Organisations must now decide whether climate change is a relevant issue (clause 4.1) and whether interested parties have climate-related requirements (clause 4.2). Many systems certified before the amendment have not been updated.
Fix: add climate change to your context analysis, even if your conclusion is that it has a limited effect. Record the reasoning, and list any related requirements from customers, regulators or other interested parties.
8. KPIs set but never reviewed
Companies often set departmental KPIs and objectives, then never discuss the results. Clause 9.3 requires management review to consider performance, and clause 6.2 expects objectives to have a responsible person and a plan.
Fix: assign each objective to a named person, not a department. Add a KPI review item to the management review agenda, and record the action taken when a target is missed.
At a Glance: Common Audit Findings & Quick Corrective Actions
|
Common Findings |
How to Fix Them |
|
1. Documents not reviewed |
Conduct regular document reviews. |
|
2. No internal audit findings |
Perform impartial, evidence-based internal audits. |
|
3. Outdated ISO clause references |
Update templates according to the latest ISO standards. |
|
4. Changes without risk assessment |
Review risks before implementing changes. |
|
5. Improper risk controls |
Follow the hierarchy of controls and maintain PPE records. |
|
6. Legal compliance not evaluated |
Conduct periodic compliance evaluations. |
|
7. Climate change not considered |
Include climate change in the organisational context. |
|
8. KPIs not monitored |
Review objectives and performance during management reviews. |
Checklist for the month before your surveillance audit
- Review every document on the master list and record the review date.
- Complete an internal audit with an impartial auditor and a written report.
- Hold a management review that covers audit results, objectives, KPIs, customer feedback, incidents, legal compliance and resources.
- Update the risk and aspects registers for anything that changed during the year.
- Close or update the actions from your last certification audit, with evidence.
- Check that licences, permits and contractor documents are valid.
- Add climate change to your context analysis if it is not there yet.
Conclusion
A successful ISO surveillance audit is not just about maintaining documentation or preparing for an auditor’s visit. It is about demonstrating that your management system is actively implemented, regularly monitored and continuously improved throughout the year.
By addressing these eight common findings, organisations can reduce the risk of nonconformities, improve operational performance and maintain their ISO certification with confidence.
Remember, ISO certification is not a one-time achievement; it is an ongoing commitment to quality, environmental responsibility and workplace safety.
If your organisation is preparing for its first surveillance audit, MaxiCert can support you with document reviews, internal audits, risk assessments and audit preparation for ISO 9001, ISO 14001 and ISO 45001.
Need help before your audit?
MaxiCert helps companies prepare for ISO 9001, ISO 14001 and ISO 45001 surveillance audits, from document review to internal audits. Contact us to talk about your next audit date.
Your Trusted Partner for Certification Excellence

Get In Touch

Get In Touch
FAQ
It is a shorter audit by the certification body, carried out every year between certification and recertification. It checks a sample of the system to confirm that it is still in use and still meets the standard.
No. Many companies prepare on their own. A consultant can help with an independent internal audit, a review of your documents, or closing findings from the last audit. A consultant cannot take part in certifying a system they helped to build.
The first surveillance audit must take place within 12 months of the certification decision. Your certification body sets the exact date.
Minor nonconformities do not usually affect the certificate if you send a corrective action plan on time. A major nonconformity, or failure to close findings within the deadline, can lead to suspension.
It is usually about one-third of the time of the initial certification audit. The certification body calculates the time based on the number of employees, sites and standards.